19.7 C
Monday, October 19, 2020

Amy Coney Barrett Says Legal Birth Control Not ‘In Danger Of Going Anywhere’


Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett said she doesn’t think Griswold v. Connecticut, a landmark Supreme Court case legalizing contraception, is “in danger of going anywhere,” amid concerns that President Trump’s pick for the top court could vote to roll back reproductive rights for women.

Key Facts

Answering questions from Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.) during the third day of Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearings about whether she would follow in the footsteps of her mentor, late Justice Antonin Scalia, who thought the 1965 case was wrongly decided, Barrett signaled there is no imminent danger.

“I think Griswold is not going anywhere unless you plan to pass a law prohibiting couples, all people, from using birth control,” Barrett said, adding that it’s “unthinkable any legislature would pass such a law.”

However, Barrett, as she has done with all questions she determines as asking her to “prejudge” a case, declined to say whether she thought the court came to the right conclusion. 

Coons pointed out that both Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justice Clarence Thomas said during their confirmation hearings that they agreed with the court’s conclusion in Griswold v. Connecticut

Key Background 

Due to Barrett’s conservative personal beliefs, particularly her opposition to abortion, her nomination has led to concerns that she will give the court a solid conservative majority that could strike down core legal precedents protecting women’s reproductive rights, like Roe v. Wade. Senate Democrats have pressed Barrett repeatedly on how she would rule on a challenge to Roe, citing fears inspired by President Trump’s prior statement that he would pick a Supreme Court justice ready to overturn the case providing the constitutional right to abortion. Barrett, however, has insisted that her personal beliefs are separate from her role as a judge, and that she will judge cases based on the law.

Crucial Quote 

“Judges can’t just wake up one day and say, ‘I have an agenda, I like guns, I hate guns, I like abortion, I hate abortion,’ and walk in like a royal queen and impose their will on the world,” Barrett told the committee on Tuesday. She has also sought to differentiate herself from late Justice Antonin Scalia, who she has called a mentor, saying: “I have my own mind.”

Further Reading

“Lindsey Graham Praises Amy Coney Barrett For Being ‘Unashamedly Pro-Life” (Forbes)

“‘30 Years Is A Lot To Remember’: Amy Coney Barrett Defends Signing, Failing To Disclose Anti-Abortion Letters” (Forbes)

“Amy Coney Barrett Suggests Marriage Equality Won’t Be Successfully Challenged” (Forbes)

“Amy Coney Barrett Says Roe V. Wade Is Not ‘Super-Precedent’” (Forbes)

Speak Your Mind

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Get in Touch


Recommend for You

‘This is insanity’: Doctors slam Trump’s drive to greet supporters outside Walter Reed hospital

US President Trump waves from the back of a car outside of Walter Reed Medical Center in Bethesda, Maryland on Ocotber 4, 2020.Alex Edelman...

Exclusive: Argentina First Country To Approve GMO Wheat

BUENOS AIRES: Argentina has approved HB4 drought-resistant GMO wheat by biotechnology firm Bioceres SA, the company and the government said on Wednesday, making it...

After Singapore greenlights cruises to nowhere, Genting’s Dream Cruises says inquiries are ‘coming nonstop’

SINGAPORE — First there were flights to nowhere, now there are cruises to nowhere. This week, Singapore announced a pilot program where cruises will make round...

‘Lock Up The Bidens’: Trump Picks Target For Final Stretch – His Opponent’s Family

Topline President Trump has begun focusing a disproportionate amount of his attention at campaign events on his Democratic opponent Joe Biden’s family in an...

Related Articles

More Talent Rushes To The Synthetic Biology Gold Mine:...

Synthetic biology sells picks and shovels for the $4...

This Is What Sports And City Leaders Need For...

By Arthur L. Caplan & Lee H. Igel A...

Is Attorney General William Barr Interfering With The Election?...

Democratic congressional leaders are demanding the Department of Justice open an investigation into the...

Kia Sonet SUV launched in India –Check price, specs,...

New Delhi: Kia Motors India, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Kia Motors Corporation on Friday...