18 C
Thursday, October 22, 2020

Will California Phase Out Oil-Fired Cars?

Will California’s ban on petroleum fueled vehicles by 2035 prove to be sound policy? As I said in a 2013 column on California vehicle mandates, insanity is doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different result. Past vehicle mandates have been abandoned as unworkable, and the recent electricity crisis has been blamed in part on the state’s Renewable Portfolio Standards. Could this time be different?

The reality of electric vehicle technology is that costs have come down and performance has increased significantly from the days of the ill-fated zero emission vehicle mandate that California and a number of other states adopted in the 1990s. The costs of lithium-ion batteries, which well out-perform the earlier lead-acid batteries, have come down sharply, something like 80-90% in the past decade.

Which begs the question, if electric vehicles have improved so much and are still only 5% of sales in California, why did advocates insist the technology was commercially viable a quarter-century ago? Watch “Who Killed the Electric Car?” and you will see effusive praise of the cars and nary any criticism (except of the manufacturers and oil industry). Yet Time magazine referred to the EV1 as one of the worst fifty cars of all time, noting “In fact, battery technology at the time was nowhere near ready to replace the piston-powered engine.” 

At roughly the same time as the EV1 fiasco, hydrogen fuel cell cars were also being hyped, with one manufacturer predicting six-figure sales by 2005. (U.S. sales last year were 2,000.) Indeed, the hydrogen highway later proposed by Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger was premised on the viability of the technology. “[Said Schwarzenegger’s environment adviser Terry]Tamminen, who drives a hydrogen-fueled Honda Clarity, said in an email that contrary to press reports, hydrogen fueled cars are ‘real and here right now … I refuel at the Shell station on Santa Monica Blvd…and have driven the car all over CA with no problem.’” 

The automotive market is littered with similar hyped but failed vehicle programs, including Amory Lovins’ Hypercar and the Clinton Administration’s Partnership for a Next Generation Vehicle, none of which has gained traction despite enormous amounts of hype. Which doesn’t prove that a hyped technology or vehicle won’t succeed, just that the hype should invite scrutiny, not mandates or subsidies.

Indeed, the fact of the mandate implies that the governor is wary of the arguments by so many advocates that the electric vehicle is all but ready to dominate car sales. Instead, this is one more case of trying to determine consumer purchases by regulation, rather than by incentives such as a carbon tax.

This ‘preference denialism’ is similar to science denialism, ignoring evidence to promote one’s own beliefs. In “Who Killed the Electric Car?” it is suggested that the EV1 would have succeeded if only GM had put its advertising might behind the product, since consumers are apparently sheep. (If you believe that, try standing on a street corner of any downtown and count the number of Edsels that go by.)

Could the electric vehicle outcompete petroleum-fueled cars by 2035? Yes, it is possible. It is also possible that the lithium-ion battery is nearing the limits of improvement in cost and performance, and by 2035, electric vehicles will still only account for a single-digit market share. The new California mandate will not be the determining factor the dominant technology, and it is clear that because the costs of a failed experiment will be hidden to the public (imposed primarily on auto manufacturers and indirectly on consumers), the politicians are treating this as a cost-free policy. Which should be considered more evidence of the difficult business environment in the state rather than the visionary nature of their politicians.

GristCalifornia plans no exit from hydrogen highway – Grist

TimeThe 50 Worst Cars of All Time

Speak Your Mind


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Get in Touch


Recommend for You

Sensex jumps 220 points, Nifty surges above 11,980

New Delhi: Markets opened in gren on Monday, led by gains in index-heavyweights amid largely positive global cues. The BSE Sensex rose 219.30 points or...

Air India Announces Additional Flights to London January 1, Booking Begins | Details Here

International Flights: National carrier Air India has announced additional flights...

Why Tech Giants Limited The Spread Of NY Post Story On Biden

OAKLAND, California: When Facebook and Twitter moved quickly this week to limit the spread of an unverified political story published by the conservative-leaning...

What Is The Scariest Movie Ever? Well, Science Now Has An Answer To That Question

PARK CITY, UT - JANUARY 24: Actress Maika Monroe from "It Follows" poses for a portrait at the ......

Forests That Survive Megafires Prove Good Management Trumps Climate Change

Decades of prescribed burning saved Shaver Lake forestlands from California's high-intensity ... megafire. Southern California Edison...

Related Articles

Big news for MSME sector! Government aiming to create...

New Delhi: Union Minister for Road Transport and Highways and MSME Nitin Gadkari has...

With German Renewables At Over 50%, Is 100% Renewables...

Renewable energy provided around 52% of all German power consumption in Q1 2020, an...

Revisiting Season Predictions For The Indiana Pacers

Indiana Pacers guard Aaron Holiday (3) in the first...

Brexit Supporting French Rush To Buy London Homes

Corbis via Getty Images In anticipation of Brexit...